So I found a few on the internet, passed on the $200 one, instead ordering the more "reasonably priced one." Then, I had a brain storm, and decided to make his much-anticipated Baby Jesus the surprise gift at the end of his Christmas Eve Scavenger hunt.
When we got home from the Christmas Eve Service, I took him to the first clue, written on the back of a picture next to our nativity scene. It said that some of the nativity figures were missing, and Spencer and Evelyn needed to solve the clues to help find them and put them back where they belong. He was so excited, but he refused to start the scavenger hunt until his Papa got there. Thankfully, he arrived not too much longer.